In Jose Rybertt y Cia Ltda v Montes SA, NIC Chile panellist Luis Felipe Claro
Swinburn has dismissed Montes SA's opposition to the registration of 'vinosapalta.cl'.
Claro Swinburn held that although Montes owns the FINCA DE APALTA mark, it was
using it as an appellation of origin, which merely indicates that its wine is
produced in the Apalta Valley in Chile.