In Hansruedi Raimund v Michaela Aigner (C-425/16, October 19 2017) the European Court of Justice (ECJ) issued a preliminary ruling concerning the interpretation of Article 99(1) of Council Regulation 207/2009 on an EU trademark. It stated that an infringement action brought before a national court may not be dismissed due to trademark invalidity based on absolute grounds without that court having upheld the invalidation counterclaim brought by the defendant in that infringement action and based on the same invalidity grounds. The ECJ further ruled that a national court may dismiss an infringement action based on trademark invalidity even if the decision on the invalidity counterclaim had not yet become final (res iudicata).

Want to read more?

Register to access two of our subscriber only articles per month

Subscribe for unlimited access to articles, in-depth analysis and research from the World Trademark Review experts

Already registered? Log in

What our customers are saying

I look forward to reading the World Trademark Review e-mail updates every day. WTR provides a concise summary of noteworthy disputes and legislative issues around the world, as well as helpful country-specific overviews on trademark laws and practices.

Ruby A. Zefo
Director, Trademarks & Brands Legal
Intel Corporation


Subscribe to World Trademark Review to receive access to the full range of trademark intelligence, insight, and case law, as well as our guides, rankings and daily market insight delivered to your inbox.

Why subscribe?

Share this article