World Trademark Review Issue 34 December/January 2012

Talking point: Interflora v Marks & Spencer

While the Interflora v Marks & Spencer plc ruling in some respects goes further than other decisions on the use of keywords, it also seems a natural progression from earlier case law. WTR asked a range of commentators for their reaction to the ruling, and whether it constitutes good or bad news for brand owners
Trevor Little


Inside track: BBC

The brand protection team at the publicly funded BBC must work within budgetary constraints that could confound even the thriftiest of private sector in-house teams. To compound the challenge, the infringers they must contend with may also be their shareholders
Trevor Little

Unmasking reality at the MARQUES annual conference

This year’s MARQUES annual conference was organised around the theme “Reality Check”. The realities that it considered encompassed both the physical and virtual worlds, as well as predictions for the future of brand management and the European trademark system. WTR presents the highlights of the programme
Trevor Little

At your service Premium content

Budgets are shrinking, workloads are rising and infringement is omnipresent. Against this background, accessing strategic non-legal trademark services has become increasingly crucial. But how is the industry meeting user demand and what does the future hold? In an exclusive survey, WTR polled trademark professionals for their thoughts on how the sector is matching up to their expectations, and put the responses to service providers
Trevor Little

Coming to life – solutions for protecting fictional brands in a real-world environment

The flipside of product placement, where brands enter the media world, occurs when fictional brands take flesh and are adopted in the real world. When this occurs, particular challenges arise – not least with regard to reputation issues and establishing genuine use
Benoit Michaux and Eva De Pauw

What brand owners should know about Australian consumer law

A recent case involving Marksun highlights the role that the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission can play in trademark disputes, and the need for trademark owners to understand the powers it wields
Rodney De Boos and Desmond J Ryan

Growing your eco-brands in a changing climate

As more advertisers try to engage in green marketing, the challenge to stand out increases. For brands that truly boast green credentials, it is important to know how to position your marks and align these with a credible message
Michael Tschupp

Marketing ‘smell-alikes’ in Germany: the opportunities and pitfalls

Unlike in the Netherlands, where the Dutch Supreme Court has held that perfumes are eligible for copyright protection, no such rulings have been issued in Germany. However, a recent decision provides guidance on the marketing of smell-alikes
Peter Ruess and Anja Doepner-Thiele

Ballpark figures: assessing brand value and the benefits of stadium naming rights

The rising cost of stadi um naming rights deals is bucking the economic trend, but the brand considerations are being more closely scrutinised. With a greater emphasis being placed on brand valuation methodologies to identify the true benefits of such deals, the considerations also provide useful pointers for other types of sponsorship deal
Elise Neils

Strategies and structures for effective IP management

A range of structures can be created to manage intellectual property assets, but companies need to select the correct one for their purposes – and ensure that trademark concerns are properly assessed
Lanning Gerald Bryer and Deepica Capoor Warikoo

TRIPs 2.0? Recasting the overall framework of global IP protection

With TRIPs almost 20 years old, a recent project has investigated ways to reform the agreement, culminating in a concrete set of proposals to strengthen the international IP regime. Some of the recommendations are worth further scrutiny
Annette Kur

The true impact of corruption on India’s trademark landscape Premium content

Two years ago, WTR revealed the opposition gridlock which had brought much of the activity at India’s trademark registry to a grinding halt. But no one could have predicted the turbulent 24 months that were to follow. WTR examines the impact for brand owners
Jane Denny

Trademark toolkit: letters of protest

Letters of protest to the USPTO are an underused and misunderstood tool, and their limitations are not as broad as they first appear
Jamie Pitts


Search engines the winner in Interflora decision

In Interflora v Marks & Spencer (Case C-323/09), the European Court of Justice (ECJ) has held that a trademark owner is entitled to object to the use of its mark as a keyword if internet users cannot tell whether the goods originate from the trademark owner or a third party. However, the ECJ recognised that advertisers can legitimately present themselves as commercial alternatives to the trademark owner – a positive finding for online search engines.

ACTA signed, disagreements rumble on

On October 1 2011 Australia, Canada, Japan, the Republic of Korea, Morocco, New Zealand, Singapore and the United States signed the Anti-counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA) in Japan. However, the European Union, Mexico and Switzerland – the other negotiating parties – have yet to sign, while a US senator has called for clarification over the ratification process.

OHIM makes surprise announcement over mediation

The Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (OHIM) has introduced a mediation service as an alternative to appealing to the Boards of Appeal in trademark and design cases. The service is offered by a team of specially trained mediators drawn from OHIM’s staff. The statement announcing the launch indicated that “mediation is a new departure for OHIM and one that is being offered following interest expressed by users”. Speaking after the launch, MARQUES representative Tove Graulund said that the announcement took the organisation by surprise.

BUDWEISER dispute clarifies concept of acquiescence

In Budejovicky Budvar, narodni podnik v Anheuser-Busch Inc (Case C-482/09), the ECJ has ruled that Anheuser-Busch must continue to share the BUDWEISER trademark with Budejovický Budvar when marketing its products in the United Kingdom.

Global view

For regular jurisdictional updates, see WTR Daily. Delivered straight to your inbox, WTR’s regular email news service provides legal updates, industry analysis and the editor’s pick of the best trademark content from around the globe.


Trademark management

Protecting your brand experience
Andy An, David Tian and Douglas Clark

Counterfeiting perspectives

How Australia’s Tobacco Plain Packaging Bill erodes IP rights
Jeff Hardy

The view online

Google AdWords: new opportunities for advertisers
Sascha Abrar

Co-published editorialCountry Correspondents


Canada - Bereskin & Parr LLP

In Canada, there is no express prohibition against direct comparative advertising. However, the prevalence of this practice differs greatly from sector to sector

China - Kangxin Partners PC

While existing laws do not dictate what comparative advertising practices are acceptable, given the rapid development of the advertising industry in China, more rules and regulations can be expected

Germany - Siebeke Lange Wilbert

The idea of comparative advertising being assessed equally within the European Union under a harmonised unfair competition law has gone awry

India - Ranjan Narula Associates

While India has no specific legislation governing comparative advertising, statutes on unfair trade practice and common law need to be considered. Additional lessons can be found in case law

Italy - Bugnion SpA

While a true comparison of product performance is the cornerstone of legal protection, it is only the starting point in designing an honest and fair advertisement

Mexico - Uhthoff, Gómez Vega & Uhthoff SC

The dividing line separating lawful from unlawful conduct in comparative advertising is very thin. Fortunately, Mexican law provides a set of principles and rules on the matter

Poland - Patpol - Patent & Trademark Attorneys

In Poland, advertisers have shied away from comparing products, despite the existence of a comprehensive regulatory regime for comparative advertising

Romania - Vilau & Mitel

While the global downturn has hit advertising spend, the legal framework governing practice remains steady

Russia - Gorodissky & Partners

In many cases comparative advertising is lawful, but the law demands that an advertisement be authentic. Advertisers should therefore be careful when stepping into this arena

United Kingdom - Edwards Wildman Palmer LLP

Both the ECJ and the English courts have credited comparative advertising with promoting healthy competition, but advertisers need to ensure they comply with the rules

United States - Edwards Wildman Palmer LLP

Since there is a range of legislation dictating advertising practice, investment in a proper review and clearance process is minimal compared to the potential cost of claims


Register for more free content

  • Read more World Trademark Review blogs and articles
  • Receive the editor's weekly review by email
Register now  
Issue 71